Far from the same old opposition protest

090225 Moscow T2.jpg
A "Young Russia" (pro-Kremlin youth group) member. Photo: Anton Belickiy.

Why was Saturday's opposition rally in Moscow strikingly different from previous events? Because not one protestor was beaten or arrested. Even stranger - pro-Kremlin counter activists themselves were detained by the police. Which begs the question; is the Russian government warming to the idea of freedom of speech?

The protest was organised by "Solidarnost" (Solidarity), a unification of several long-existing anti-government movements. It was the same faces and slogans that took to the streets, but for once, their event had been approved by the city authorities, and instead of the protestors facing police persecution, it was their opponents who ended up in the back of a police van.

Pro-Kremlin supporters get a taste of their own medicine

Several pro-Kremlin youths try to disrupt the Solidarnost demonstration and are subsequently taken away by police forces. Posted by "WMParovoz". 

"The authorities probably realised that total prohibition just aggravated the situation"

Anna Karetnikova is an anti-war movement activist.

I'm not keen to see this as a ‘thawing' caused by a change of tact from Putin and Medvedev, or the relationship between [Moscow mayor] Luzhkov and Putin, as public opinion would have it. Rather, I see it as a result of two factors.

The first is an unprecedented amount of pressure - countless meetings, consultations, round tables, firm demands - from human rights activists on the government and the CIAD in connection with the prohibition of a demonstration in memoriam of Markelov and Baburina.

The second is that not just National Bolsheviks, but even young liberals have started to use ‘peaceful guerrilla' tactics: as meetings are constantly prohibited they've stopped applying for approval and instead make sudden demonstrations in unexpected places - which allow the demonstrators to escape arrest.

Because of these two things the authorities probably realised that total prohibition just aggravated the situation. As I understand it, the first people to understand that were the CIAD."

Anna Karetnikova's picture

Anna Karetni...

  • Russia
  • Anti-war demonstrator

"I don't think we should be misguided by this softened tone"

Roman Dobrokhotov is one of the leaders of "My" (We) opposition movement.

The reason why the authorities' attitude has changed is that they're trying to alleviate tensions in times of economic crisis. Two weeks ago the chief police department (CIAD) invited us and human rights activists to a discussion because we'd protested the CIAD encouraging universities to dismiss students that took part in opposition marches. They promised to start an internal investigation within their office, find the culprit and make an apology. We haven't received the apology yet, but we can see other signs of change. For instance, we decided to organise a meeting on St. Valentine's day and, for the first time in years, they didn't prohibit the event but just replied that they received our notification according to law.

However, I don't think we should be misguided by this softened tone. We were still prohibited from protesting by the city hall because it could allegedly cause harm to a monument there, while the city hall itself organises public events near there all the time.

Don't forget that a contrary move - to tighten the screws - also exists. At the end of January I was detained for five days for going to Russian White House with empty white posters and our mouths sealed with tape. We were accused of swearing! These are Byelorussian police methods that haven't been used in Russia since the Soviet times."

Roman Dobrokhotov's picture

Roman Dobrok...

  • Russia
  • Opposition activist

More images of the unusual arrests

Photos by Anton Belickiy.

Comments

Riots in Russia

Poutin flies Riot Police units to Vladivostok, so does Sarko, who fly CRS to Gouadeloupe/Martinique, where France faces a major colonial problem!
The difference is that Vladivostok was/is the center of an illegal trade in old Japanese cars (with right hands directions, illegal in Russia), that was tolerated in the 90's, but not anymore, and Moscow plans to put a stop to it.
And it has nothing to do with democracy or lack of it under Poutin and CO.
As far as Journalists being arrested in Russia, reporting on mass manifestations, just check the lack of Main Media reporting, on the number of US newspersons arrested in Minneapolis/St.Paul during the Republican Convention, or in Denver for the Democrat's Convention!

Unregistered user

Why did governement send

Why did governement send riot police from Moscow region instead of using local forces? They wanted beat and intimidate people and avoid any possibility of investigation --which is regular practice for Russia nowdays.

Unregistered user